Archive for February 21st, 2006


New Canon EF-S 17-55mm f/2.8 IS ?! & My Canon 30D Rant

Posted by Aric on February 21st, 2006


Well, I was wrong again when the rumor of a Canon EF-S 17-55mm lens surfaced. I incorrectly guessed that the 17-55mm EF-S would be a replacement for the EF-S 18-55mm “kit lens”. People had speculated that a 17-55mm with f/2.8 or image stabilization would fit nicely into Canon’s lineup. I, as well as others, speculated that Canon would not build a f/2.8 EF-S lens, much less build image stabilization into an EF-S f/2.8.

Well, looks like I was wrong.

Here’s the proof:

http://web.canon.jp/Imaging/eos30d/sample/sample1.html

The lens used to shoot this picture is stated on Canon.jp’s website as:

EF-S 17-55mm f/2.8 IS USM

Frankly, I’m a little surprised.. although if the price is right (and EF-S is supposed to be cheaper, right?!), I’d really consider this lens..

UPDATE 3:19PM: Here’s a pic taken from the Canon 30D White Paper.. MSRP $1,149!

Canon's new EF-S 17-55mm f/2.8 IS

Oh, also, I wanted to say something about Canon’s 30D. Reading lots of the posts over at the quagmine known as dpreview.com, you’ll read lots of posts about how Canon has let “us” down with the 30D (since its only a slight upgrade to the 20D).. you’ll hear people proclaim that they’re going to abandon the Canon line in favor of the Nikon D200..

What I dont understand is, what the hell are these people talking about? If you own a 20D, were you really that serious about upgrading to the 30D (now before you call me a hipocrate, I’m in a slightly different situation and yes, I will be upgrading)? When I had my Canon Digital Rebel 300D, I watched patiently as hordes of people flocked to the Digital Rebel XT 350D or even the Canon 20D. I definitely could’ve used the upgrade from 300D to 350D. I played with the numbers, trying to figure out an economical way of upgrading.. but in the end, it was hard to justify for me. It wasn’t until I started shooting more motorsports until I really could appreciate an upgrade. But by the time I had made that decision, my Digital Rebel 300D had about 11,000 actuations on the shutter. To many, that’s a lifetime of pictures. To me, it was about a years worth. To Canon, that’s about a 1/3 of the useful life of the 300D’s shutter (I think). I’d be willing to bet that a lot of the people who complain about the Canon 30D not being worth the upgrade from a 20D are people with less than 5,00o actuations, maybe even less. In other words, I doubt these people have even used their Canon 20D’s to the point that their camera has outlived its usefulness. Even then, I had toyed with the idea of keeping my 300D because it still took great pictures.

The Canon 30D is not meant to address 20D upgraders. For Canon to honestly believe that a fair amount of existing Canon 20D owners were going to pull the trigger and pay for the upgrade to a 30D would’ve been ridiculous. I’m sure they’d love to believe that, but I’d bet the market research (and in most cases, the pure common sense of the idea) don’t support that belief. Rather, the Canon 30D is meant to address those upgrading from the D30, D60, 10D, 300D, or even the 350D. Following this line of reasoning, the Canon 5D is meant for people wishing to upgrade from the Canon 20D, 350D, 300D, etc. In fact, now rumors are circulating that a lower-priced, “de-tuned”, Canon 5D will make its way to market sometime before or around June 2006. As much as I would like a full-frame DSLR, if the Canon 5D is only 3fps, I’m sure the Canon 5D “Lite” isn’t going to be faster than that. And unfortunately, I love the speed of the Canon 20D/30D. Think about this.. Canon will price the 30D slightly above the Nikon D70s. Although it is debatable, I think most would agree the Canon 30D will be a better option over a Nikon D70s. Now, price the 30D below the Nikon D200 to appeal to the price sensitive consumers wishing to explore DSLRs. Now, introduce a full-frame camera that will smoke any APS-C crop sensor DSLR. Price that slightly above the Nikon D200. Its conceivable that Canon could effectively position their products at price points that could make the Nikon lineup non-competitive. Nikon will have basically brought a “knife” to Canon’s “gun” fight.

Here’s the scenario:

    1. Point and shoot consumer wishes to explore DSLR photography, he/she has friends who own Canon and Nikon
    2. Nikon’s D50 can’t compare to Canon’s 350D even though the D50 is cheaper. Meaning, the small increase in price is justified in purchasing the 350D.
    3. Consumer decides to look one level up, Nikon’s D70 versus the Canon 30D
    4. Again, the small price increase to move from the D70 to the 30D are justified (8mp, faster FPS, better IQ, etc)
    5. Consumer decided to go up one more level, Nikon’s D200 versus the Canon 5D Lite
    6. Should he/she pay $1700 for a 1.5x 10mp camera or a $2,000 12mp full-frame camera?

True, all this depends on whether or not Canon introduces a 5D Lite, but based on my scenario, what do you think?

Keep in mind, all this marketing crap is directed towards NEW DSLR owners. Once you’ve collected enough Canon lenses, Canon has to assume they’ve won your business and brand loyalty. True, its not always the case, but thats kind of like buying 3 Honda engines for your Civic, then buying a Chevy for your next car, its mostly illogical.







The new Canon EOS 30D

Posted by Aric on February 21st, 2006


UPDATE September,18 2006: Click here for latest Canon 40D and Canon 7D rumors!

Well, as promised, Canon has introduced the new successor to the Canon 20D, the Canon 30D. You can probably find a lot more info at Canon’s own website, but here’s a quick rundown and a nice picture of the new Canon 30D:

Canon's official picture of the Canon 30D

The New Canon 30D

Here’s whats new:

From www.robgalbraith.com:
- A new 2.5-inch, 230,000 pixel rear LCD monitor with wide viewing angle
- Canon’s more flexible Picture Style menu, which replaces the Parameters menu of the 20D
- Sharpening of in-camera JPEGs can be turned off, which is a first for a Canon entry-level or midrange digital SLR
- ISO 100-1600 is now selectable in 1/3 stop increments
- ISO can be set without taking one’s eye away from the viewfinder
- Increased burst depth: 11 frames for RAW CR2 shooting, 30 for Large Fine JPEG and 9 for RAW+JPEG
- A more-durable shutter that’s rated for 100,000 cycles
- A slightly-shortened mirror blackout time of 110ms; Canon’s specification for shutter lag remains the same as the 20D at 65ms
- Viewfinder information now includes a dedicated Flash Exposure Lock (FEL) indicator
- Switchable High-Speed Continuous (5 fps) and Low-Speed Continuous (3 fps) frame rate settings are now included
- An Auto setting in the Long Exposure Noise Reduction Custom Function
- The ability, like several more-pricey Canon digital SLRs, to simultaneously apply long exposure noise processing to one picture while capturing another
- The addition of a 3.5% spot metering mode
- 0.15 second camera startup time
- A more-precise 4-increment battery charge indicator
- Reduced energy compensation, for a promised improvement of 10% more frames per charge
- No more new folders created every 100 photos; in the 30D, a folder can hold 9999 photos
- A new automatic rotation option that enables verticals to not be rotated on the rear display but appear rotated in compatible browser software on the computer
- The ability to zoom in on a photo in Quick Review mode
- During playback, the image+shooting data screen will display either an RGB or Brightness histogram, file size and will optionally display AF markings
- Improved Jump function
- Refined multicontroller operation
- More-detailed error code information, which now appears on the rear LCD monitor (in addition to the top LCD panel); the camera settings information screen will also display Images Failed to Transfer when the WFT-E1/E1A is in use and a transmit error occurs
- More ways to wake the camera up from an Auto Power Off snooze
- Direct image transfer from the camera to a computer using the PTP protocol
- A revamped software package that includes Digital Photo Professional (DPP) 2.1, EOS Utility 1.0 (a new image transfer, camera settings and camera control application), Image Browser 5.6 (Mac) and ZoomBrowser EX 5.6 (Windows); DPP adds user-settable noise reduction and support for RAW files from the Canon EOS D2000 and D6000
- New and potentially useful direct printing capabilities (plus a dedicated direct print/image transfer button)

Things to note:

- ISO can be set without taking one’s eye away from the viewfinder (ISO in viewfinder?!)
- Switchable 5fps or 3fps
- Bigger buffer, 11 frames for RAW CR2 shooting, 30 for Large Fine JPEG and 9 for RAW+JPEG
- The addition of a 3.5% spot metering mode
- A more-precise 4-increment battery charge indicator (more-precise? 4 segments vs 3?!)
- ISO 100-1600 is now selectable in 1/3 stop increments
- 2.5″ LCD
- Same 8.19 megapixels (whoa, interesting Canon would not try to compete with Nikon in this aspect) :oops:
- IT USES THE BG-E2, same battery grip as the Canon 20D!

Personally, I dont see a real need to update from the Canon 20D to the new Canon 30D. Of course, some of the features listed here may prove to be more useful than immediately apparent. I guess we should just wait for the reviews to roll in to see if the Canon 30D performs better than the Canon 20D.. it doesnt seem so.. but you never know.. let the debate begin :lol: ..